1. Home
  2. Indiana

Best Consignment Stores in Indiana

Discover 50 carefully selected consignment stores across 44 cities in Indiana. Find quality secondhand furniture, clothing, antiques, and more at great prices.

50 Total Stores
44 Cities

All Consignment Stores in Indiana

Complete directory of consignment shops with store details and contact information

Plato's Closet - Consignment Store

Plato's Closet

★★★★★
(862 reviews)
📍 8680 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037
🏢 Fishers, IN
📞+1 317-585-0868
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Uptown Cheapskate Fort Wayne - Consignment Store

Uptown Cheapskate Fort Wayne

★★★★★
(747 reviews)
📍 4025 Ice Way, Fort Wayne, IN 46805
🏢 Fort Wayne, IN
📞+1 260-755-5189
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Affordable, Clean & Organized
Plato's Closet - Consignment Store

Plato's Closet

★★★★★
(602 reviews)
📍 9871 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123
🏢 Avon, IN
📞+1 317-220-8288
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Once Upon A Child Bloomington - Consignment Store

Once Upon A Child Bloomington

★★★★★
(532 reviews)
📍 3368 W 3rd St, Bloomington, IN 47404
🏢 Bloomington, IN
📞+1 812-339-1050
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Treasure Mart Antique Mall - Consignment Store

Treasure Mart Antique Mall

★★★★★
(441 reviews)
📍 116 W Alto Rd, Kokomo, IN 46902
🏢 Kokomo, IN
📞+1 765-455-9855
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Hanover Flea Market - Consignment Store

Hanover Flea Market

★★★★★
(348 reviews)
📍 162 W Lagrange Rd, Hanover, IN 47243
🏢 Hanover, IN
📞+1 812-866-8500
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Trader Buck's - Consignment Store

Trader Buck's

★★★★★
(330 reviews)
📍 1921 E 53rd St, Anderson, IN 46013
🏢 Anderson, IN
📞+1 765-393-3642
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Once Upon A Child - Consignment Store

Once Upon A Child

★★★★★
(297 reviews)
📍 1950 E Greyhound Pass Suite 13, Carmel, IN 46033
🏢 Carmel, IN
📞+1 317-815-6822
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Paul's Auto Yard - Consignment Store

Paul's Auto Yard

★★★★★
(257 reviews)
📍 1501 Lake St, Lake Station, IN 46405
🏢 Lake Station, IN
📞+1 844-226-7272
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Mission 27 Resale - Consignment Store

Mission 27 Resale

★★★★★
(250 reviews)
📍 1618 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
🏢 Indianapolis, IN
📞+1 317-687-8260
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Habitat For Humanity Of Johnson County Restore - Consignment Store

Habitat For Humanity Of Johnson County Restore

★★★★★
(246 reviews)
📍 6720 N U.S. 31, Whiteland, IN 46184
🏢 Whiteland, IN
📞+1 317-535-6720
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
The Amish Mall - Consignment Store

The Amish Mall

★★★★★
(221 reviews)
📍 1216 W Bristol St, Elkhart, IN 46514
🏢 Elkhart, IN
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Santa's Toys - Consignment Store

Santa's Toys

★★★★★
(204 reviews)
📍 3 Kringle Pl, Santa Claus, IN 47579
🏢 Santa Claus, IN
📞+1 812-937-6050
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Habitat For Humanity - Consignment Store

Habitat For Humanity

★★★★★
(198 reviews)
📍 116 S Walnut St, Plymouth, IN 46563
🏢 Plymouth, IN
📞+1 574-935-4214
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Vendor City - Consignment Store

Vendor City

★★★★★
(173 reviews)
📍 537 S Reed Rd, Kokomo, IN 46901
🏢 Kokomo, IN
📞+1 765-450-7374
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
The Outpost - Consignment Store

The Outpost

★★★★★
(173 reviews)
📍 113 IN-135, Trafalgar, IN 46181
🏢 Trafalgar, IN
📞+1 317-878-5928
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
St. Martin Community Center - Consignment Store

St. Martin Community Center

★★★★★
(169 reviews)
📍 901 S Branson St, Marion, IN 46953
🏢 Marion, IN
📞+1 765-651-9324
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Bargain Bill's Of Salem Indiana - Consignment Store

Bargain Bill's Of Salem Indiana

★★★★★
(158 reviews)
📍 1201 W Mulberry St, Salem, IN 47167
🏢 Salem, IN
📞+1 812-586-0477
🏷️ Clothing, Affordable, Clean & Organized
Green Door - Consignment Store

Green Door

★★★★★
(144 reviews)
📍 325 Main St, Hobart, IN 46342
🏢 Hobart, IN
📞+1 219-203-0598
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized

Style Encore - Terre Haute

★★★★★
(126 reviews)
📍 4432 S US Hwy 41 #95, Terre Haute, IN 47802
🏢 Terre Haute, IN
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Goodwill Industries - Auburn Store - Consignment Store

Goodwill Industries - Auburn Store

★★★★★
(114 reviews)
📍 1003 W Seventh St, Auburn, IN 46706
🏢 Auburn, IN
📞+1 260-572-0042
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Brumfield & Hart Consignment - Consignment Store

Brumfield & Hart Consignment

★★★★★
(111 reviews)
📍 402 N Hart St, Princeton, IN 47670
🏢 Princeton, IN
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Midwest Antiques And Collectables - Consignment Store

Midwest Antiques And Collectables

★★★★★
(95 reviews)
📍 439 E IN-64, English, IN 47118
🏢 English, IN
📞+1 812-338-9663
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
On The Way Mini-Mart - Consignment Store

On The Way Mini-Mart

★★★★★
(83 reviews)
📍 9356 IN-44, Manilla, IN 46150
🏢 Manilla, IN
📞+1 765-544-2279
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized

Resale To The Rescue

★★★★★
(79 reviews)
📍 905 W McKinley Ave, Mishawaka, IN 46545
🏢 Mishawaka, IN
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Habitat For Humanity Restore - Consignment Store

Habitat For Humanity Restore

★★★★★
(79 reviews)
📍 3970 Corridor Dr, Warsaw, IN 46582
🏢 Warsaw, IN
📞+1 574-269-4104
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Petunia's Antiques & Treasures - Consignment Store

Petunia's Antiques & Treasures

★★★★★
(75 reviews)
📍 1442 W 18th St, Rochester, IN 46975
🏢 Rochester, IN
📞+1 574-224-2200
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Found - Consignment Store

Found

★★★★★
(69 reviews)
📍 208 S Main St, Goshen, IN 46526
🏢 Goshen, IN
📞+1 574-534-4394
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Y Shop Vintage And More - Consignment Store

Y Shop Vintage And More

★★★★★
(68 reviews)
📍 609 Main St, Beech Grove, IN 46107
🏢 Beech Grove, IN
📞+1 317-652-0255
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Cooperative Shoppes - Consignment Store

Cooperative Shoppes

★★★★★
(62 reviews)
📍 512 State St, La Porte, IN 46350
🏢 La Porte, IN
📞+1 219-575-7535
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Miami Village Consignment Shoppe - Consignment Store

Miami Village Consignment Shoppe

★★★★★
(59 reviews)
📍 2123 Miami St, South Bend, IN 46613
🏢 South Bend, IN
📞+1 574-287-2655
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Style Threads Consignment - Consignment Store

Style Threads Consignment

★★★★★
(55 reviews)
📍 7728 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123
🏢 Avon, IN
📞+1 317-271-9500
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Brown's Antiques & Lampshade Store - Consignment Store

Brown's Antiques & Lampshade Store

★★★★★
(55 reviews)
📍 315 N 5th St, Zionsville, IN 46077
🏢 Zionsville, IN
📞+1 317-908-1396
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Vevay Vintage Prop & Shop - Consignment Store

Vevay Vintage Prop & Shop

★★★★★
(48 reviews)
📍 321 Ferry St, Vevay, IN 47043
🏢 Vevay, IN
📞+1 812-493-9572
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Traditional Arts Today - Consignment Store

Traditional Arts Today

★★★★★
(48 reviews)
📍 314 W 9th St, Ferdinand, IN 47532
🏢 Ferdinand, IN
📞+1 812-998-2487
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Colonial Antiques - Consignment Store

Colonial Antiques

★★★★★
(46 reviews)
📍 11867 US-41, Farmersburg, IN 47850
🏢 Farmersburg, IN
📞+1 812-696-2600
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Davis On Main - Consignment Store

Davis On Main

★★★★★
(43 reviews)
📍 317 N Main St, Evansville, IN 47711
🏢 Evansville, IN
📞+1 812-422-7368
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Still Stylish Consignment - Consignment Store

Still Stylish Consignment

★★★★★
(42 reviews)
📍 837 W 3rd St, Rushville, IN 46173
🏢 Rushville, IN
📞+1 765-932-3755
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Estate Recovery Resale - Consignment Store

Estate Recovery Resale

★★★★★
(42 reviews)
📍 931 Lincolnway W, Osceola, IN 46561
🏢 Osceola, IN
📞+1 574-214-6687
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Village Mercantile - Consignment Store

Village Mercantile

★★★★★
(40 reviews)
📍 123 S 2nd St, Boonville, IN 47601
🏢 Boonville, IN
📞+1 812-897-5687
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Paper Moon - Consignment Store

Paper Moon

★★★★★
(39 reviews)
📍 188 2nd St, Roanoke, IN 46783
🏢 Roanoke, IN
📞+1 260-676-2020
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
North Spencer Community Action - Consignment Store

North Spencer Community Action

★★★★★
(39 reviews)
📍 5 N Washington St, Dale, IN 47523
🏢 Dale, IN
📞+1 812-937-2796
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Attic Window - Consignment Store

Attic Window

★★★★★
(38 reviews)
📍 1725 S Liberty St, Muncie, IN 47302
🏢 Muncie, IN
📞+1 765-288-9122
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
White Lion Antiques - Consignment Store

White Lion Antiques

★★★★★
(37 reviews)
📍 113 S Main St, Kirklin, IN 46050
🏢 Kirklin, IN
📞+1 765-279-5777
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Antiques, Clean & Organized
Wyatt's Furniture - Consignment Store

Wyatt's Furniture

★★★★★
(36 reviews)
📍 933 W 5th St, Anderson, IN 46016
🏢 Anderson, IN
📞+1 765-644-4501
🏷️ Clothing, Furniture, Clean & Organized
Thriftalicious - Consignment Store

Thriftalicious

★★★★★
(36 reviews)
📍 75 W Market St, Wabash, IN 46992
🏢 Wabash, IN
📞+1 260-225-3505
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Affordable, Clean & Organized
Richland-Bean Blossom Family Store - Consignment Store

Richland-Bean Blossom Family Store

★★★★★
(35 reviews)
📍 3635 IN-46, Bloomington, IN 47404
🏢 Bloomington, IN
📞+1 812-876-6292
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Simply Home Store - Consignment Store

Simply Home Store

★★★★★
(30 reviews)
📍 948 W Main St, Boonville, IN 47601
🏢 Boonville, IN
📞+1 812-641-1611
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Furniture, Clean & Organized
Upscale Vendor Mart (Flea Market) - Consignment Store

Upscale Vendor Mart (Flea Market)

★★★★★
(29 reviews)
📍 1030 E Main St, Gas City, IN 46933
🏢 Gas City, IN
📞+1 765-573-4498
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized
Gigi's On Main - Consignment Store

Gigi's On Main

★★★★★
(28 reviews)
📍 226 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46516
🏢 Elkhart, IN
📞+1 574-343-2894
🌐Visit Website
🏷️ Clothing, Clean & Organized

Browse by City in Indiana

Explore consignment stores in specific cities

Anderson
2 consignment stores
Auburn
1 consignment stores
Avon
2 consignment stores
Beech Grove
1 consignment stores
Bloomington
2 consignment stores
Boonville
2 consignment stores
Carmel
1 consignment stores
Dale
1 consignment stores
Elkhart
2 consignment stores
English
1 consignment stores
Evansville
1 consignment stores
Farmersburg
1 consignment stores
Ferdinand
1 consignment stores
Fishers
1 consignment stores
Fort Wayne
1 consignment stores
Gas City
1 consignment stores
Goshen
1 consignment stores
Hanover
1 consignment stores
Hobart
1 consignment stores
Indianapolis
1 consignment stores
Kirklin
1 consignment stores
Kokomo
2 consignment stores
La Porte
1 consignment stores
Lake Station
1 consignment stores
Manilla
1 consignment stores
Marion
1 consignment stores
Mishawaka
1 consignment stores
Muncie
1 consignment stores
Osceola
1 consignment stores
Plymouth
1 consignment stores
Princeton
1 consignment stores
Roanoke
1 consignment stores
Rochester
1 consignment stores
Rushville
1 consignment stores
Salem
1 consignment stores
Santa Claus
1 consignment stores
South Bend
1 consignment stores
Terre Haute
1 consignment stores
Trafalgar
1 consignment stores
Vevay
1 consignment stores
Wabash
1 consignment stores
Warsaw
1 consignment stores
Whiteland
1 consignment stores
Zionsville
1 consignment stores

Complete City Directory for Indiana

All cities with consignment stores in Indiana:

Anderson (2), Auburn (1), Avon (2), Beech Grove (1), Bloomington (2), Boonville (2), Carmel (1), Dale (1), Elkhart (2), English (1), Evansville (1), Farmersburg (1), Ferdinand (1), Fishers (1), Fort Wayne (1), Gas City (1), Goshen (1), Hanover (1), Hobart (1), Indianapolis (1), Kirklin (1), Kokomo (2), La Porte (1), Lake Station (1), Manilla (1), Marion (1), Mishawaka (1), Muncie (1), Osceola (1), Plymouth (1), Princeton (1), Roanoke (1), Rochester (1), Rushville (1), Salem (1), Santa Claus (1), South Bend (1), Terre Haute (1), Trafalgar (1), Vevay (1), Wabash (1), Warsaw (1), Whiteland (1), Zionsville (1)

About Consignment Shopping in Indiana

Indiana offers excellent opportunities for consignment shopping across its 44 cities. From major urban centers to smaller towns, you'll find quality consignment stores offering everything from designer clothing to vintage furniture and antiques.

Types of Consignment Stores in Indiana

  • Clothing Consignment: Designer and brand-name clothing, shoes, and accessories
  • Furniture Consignment: Quality used furniture for every room
  • Antique Consignment: Vintage items, collectibles, and unique finds
  • General Consignment: Mixed merchandise including household items, books, and more